Elston supports UK financial advisers CIP/CRP/MPS
  • WHO WE ARE
    • About
    • Our Journey
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Elston MPS >
      • Our Portfolios
      • Adaptive Portfolios
      • Retirement Portfolios
      • Multi-Asset Income
      • Money Market Portfolio
    • Custom MPS >
      • Custom Portfolios
    • CGT Solutions >
      • Our CGT Solutions
      • GIA Portfolios
      • Onshore Bonds
      • Direct Gilts
    • Adviser Support >
      • Our Adviser Support
      • CIRP
      • Investment Committee Support
      • Regulatory Support
      • Analytics, Factsheets & Reporting
      • CPD
    • Fund Solutions >
      • Our Funds
      • Custom Funds
    • Index Solutions >
      • Our Indices
      • Elston Multi-Asset Indices
      • Sector Equal Weight
      • UK Equity Income
      • Liquid Real Assets
      • Gold and Precious Metals
      • Custom Indices
  • WHO WE HELP
    • Financial Advisers
    • Discretionary Managers
  • Insights
  • Contact

Asset Allocation Research for UK Advisers

UK Equity Income: a passion for dividends

19/5/2025

 
Picture
In this article we explore the origins of a systematic UK Equity Income strategy now powered by Elston’s Minerva™.

Read More

UK equities are a helpful value-factor proxy

15/5/2025

 
Picture
UK equities are a helpful value-factor proxy.  Value-based investing is a persistent driver of returns over time.  But not all the time.  We explore UK equities’ embedded factor tilt and how it can help diversification.

Read More

2024 investment review

3/1/2025

 
Picture
[5 min read, read as pdf]
​
  • The US economy outperformed expectations
  • The long-awaited pivot came through
  • Portfolio resilience proved key

As we look forward to 2025, it is worth revisiting the themes and predictions of our 2024 outlook “turning the corner” to get a sense of what we anticipated at the time, how this informed our recommendations to UK adviser firms’ investment committees.  Asset class performance for 2024 is summarised in the chart above.  Our 2025 outlook is published separately.
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter to get all our insights to your inbox (for UK financial advisers only)

Steady as she slows
In 2024, we anticipated a gradual deceleration in the U.S. economy, with markets pricing in the likelihood of a slight recession. In the event, the U.S. economy surprised on the upside. Growth forecasts were upgraded from 1.15% at the start of the year to an impressive 2.6% by year-end. This revision supported robust equity market returns and served as a reminder of the resilience of U.S. economic fundamentals.  In summary, a resilient US economy defied expectations.
What did we recommend to our clients at the outset and during the year? We took a balanced view between accepting concentration risk (traditional S&P 500) and diversified (active, sector exposures).  We also recommended clients lean in to broader US equity corporate landscape via 1) Equal Weight and 2) US Small Caps exposures.
By contrast, the UK had that shrinking feeling as regards economic growth, and although out of a technical recession, we are not confident of its prospects relative to the US.

Pause before pivot
At the close of 2023, we were focused on the Federal Reserve’s pause in interest rate hikes, noting that a rate cut was a question of when, not if. While the consensus view was that the first cut would be announced by mid-2024, we anticipated that the timing would hinge on the performance and strength of the U.S. economy. Indeed, the economy’s resilience delayed the start of what we anticipate to be a rate-cutting cycle to September 2024, when the Federal Reserve finally delivered a significant 50-basis-point cut.
In fact, the eventual BoE Fed pivot came a month or two later than we had estimated at the start of the year, but we recommended our clients remain dynamic with regards to duration management.  We recommended clients go strongly overweight duration in June as a good time to extend duration ahead of BoE cuts, with Fed following suit, and we saw the additional duration deliver returns on the bond side of the portfolio before attention shifted to debt supply and the UK budget later in the year, which led us to recommending to move back to neutral.

The importance of portfolio resilience
Our focus on resilience proved vital when it came to navigating the key macro factors in 2024: Growth, Inflation and Interest Rates.
For Growth, anticipating a soft landing for the US economy, we highlighted the potential outperformance of cyclical sectors, and momentum, yield and size factors. In the event, momentum emerged as the best-performing factor, with yield and size also delivering strong returns. For Rates, we adjusted duration exposure mid-year to capture the effect of falling policy rates, aligning portfolios with a changing interest rate environment. For Inflation, which remained above target, the inclusion of liquid real assets (but to a lesser extent than in 2022) and shorter duration inflation-linked bonds, ensured continued portfolio resilience.  We continue to emphasise the importance of a diversified alternatives exposure from a correlation perspective, not just in name.
Our recommendation to consider Private Market Managers and Gold & Precious Metals paid off during the year – as these were the best performing asset classes for the year, outperforming world and US equities.

Political and Geopolitical risks
In a year of elections, we saw a change in government in the UK and in the US following Trump’s Presidential win.  Both have a greater impact on bond yields and currency dynamics than equity markets, in our view.
Geopolitical risks remain elevated with the Russia-Ukraine war continuing to grind, escalating conflict and contagion in the Middle East – all at tragic human cost.

Conclusion
Markets did indeed turn a corner in 2024, with economic growth, earnings and equity market returns outperforming expectations.  With 2024 in the rear-view mirror, it’s time to look ahead to 2025.  Our 2025 outlook is published separately.

Henry Cobbe, CFA
Head of Research, Elston Consulting

UK equities: a useful diversifier

16/8/2024

 
Picture
[5 min read, open as pdf]
  • UK and US performance differential has been extreme
  • UK wealth managers have progressively reduced “home bias”
  • But UK equities are now a useful diversifier
Read in full

Why does the UK equity allocation decision matter so much
The difference between the best performing and worst performing multi-asset discretionary investment managers has largely been a function of one key decision: to what extent have they had a UK equity home bias?
Home bias means having an above index-weight in your domestic market.  Academic research on home bias tends to be written from a US perspective, so its conclusions are less relevant for UK asset allocators.
Within equities, the performance differential between the US and UK has been so extreme over the last decade or so , that this has been the singlemost important decision that has impacted portfolio performance – far more so than any active or passive debate, or active fund selections.
For financial advisers that rely on third party asset allocation providers, the decision has been made for you, and your clients’ portfolio performance becomes a function of your chosen risk profiling tool.
For the last decade or so, multi-asset portfolios that have had a low or no UK equity home bias have performed best.  Those that have a high bias have performed worst.
Choose your strategic asset allocation carefully
To show this, see the chart below which shows the “Capital Allocation Line” linking the UK Risk Free Rate (SONIA) to a) world equity risk-return (represented by an index-tracking ETF), b) UK equities risk-return (represented by an index-tracking ETF), and c) a 80/20 allocation between the two.
The risk-return for a 20%, 40%, 60%, 80% and 100% equity/cash portfolio would sit on each Capital Allocation Line with increasing increments of volatility (as percentage equity risk broadly translates to the proportion of annualised equity volatility).
Portfolio performance is broadly a function of which Capital Allocation Line a portfolio’s Strategic Asset Allocation has been constructed around.  When reviewing multi-asset managers, it makes sense to do so relative to these Capital Allocation Lines.

Fig.1. Multi-asset portfolios are built with no, partial, or high home bias
​[see pdf version]
Given the stark relative performance between portfolios built with a high bias and those built with no bias, it’s no surprise that UK institutional investors and UK wealth managers have been gradually deallocating from their home market.  Adding to the UK market’s woes, its weight in global equity indices has also been shrinking.
UK equities in a multi-asset portfolio
The gradual relative shrinkage of UK equities within global equity indices is well documented.  The decline has become more noticeable since December 2019 as the tech rally started to gain pace.  UK listed companies now make up approximately just 4% of the global equity benchmark.  Put differently, the largest US technology company is today worth almost the same as the entire FTSE 100.  It wasn’t forever so.  UK equities have shrunk from representing about 10% of global equities (developed and emerging markets combined) as recently as 2011. 
The shrinkage is a function of simple maths.  A far greater number of the rest of the world’s listed companies (predominantly the US) have grown their earnings (and hence market capitalisation) far more than the UK’s listed companies.  As a result, the UK’s relative size has shrunk.  The problem is now being compounded by the number of large, listed companies shrinking further as some move their listings to the US to obtain a better valuation, and others being acquired and becoming privately owned.  To reverse this trend, London needs to remain an attractive destination to base, list and grow companies from around the world.
UK wealth managers have been de-allocating gradually
UK discretionary investment managers have been deallocating from UK equities as they removed their “home bias.” 
In 2000, approximately 70% of a “balanced” portfolio’s equity allocation was in UK equities based on MSCI PIMFA (formerly FTSE APCIMS data[1]), compared to 33% today.  This allocation is determined to be reflective of PIMFA’s member firms by an index committee including representatives from leading UK wealth managers[2].
The chart below shows the UK equity proportion or “home bias” used in UK wealth management benchmarks based on MSCI PIMFA and FTSE APCIMS data, and an estimate of the UK equity allocation within global equity index funds. 
Fig.2. UK wealth managers have gradually reduced their home bias over time
[see pdf version] 
How much is enough?
In our work with UK financial advisers and wealth managers, we found a range of opinions.  We have always considered a UK equity allocation of 30-50% to be too high, even though that was often the existing default for firms using third party asset allocation models and the largest UK wealth managers that govern the reference benchmarks above.
Whilst intellectually we can (and did) make the case for no home bias[3] (consistent with other institutional investors and consultants), we found that adviser firms in the retail market (and indeed their end clients) would be more focused on the FTSE 100 and would want and expect to see a range of UK-focused funds in a portfolio.
Furthermore, whereas the well-known SPIVA®[4] studies evidence that in highly efficient markets (such as the US) it is challenging for active managers to persistently outperform the index, the same studies show that in less efficient markets (such as UK small-caps), active managers can persistently outperform the index[5].
On this basis, we alighted on a target 20% UK equity allocation as a mid-point between a high bias of 40% and no bias (index weight).
Twenty’s plenty
Deciding what UK equity allocation to have is a key part of a strategic asset allocation discussion for investment committees of wealth management firms and financial adviser firms alike.  For those that rely on third-party asset allocation models, the decision is made for you. 
A benchmark where the strategic asset allocation is constantly changing can be a challenge to evaluate long-run performance as the framework is always changing.  In our multi-asset indices for GBP-based investors[6], we therefore use this static 20% UK home bias equity allocation as a “neutral” for the entire index history and going forward.
This means that our benchmark has a consistent (unchanging) framework, that creates a theoretical “neutral” allocation, which UK managers and advisers can either adopt or allocate against.  Whilst customising an index to reflect one view won’t keep everybody happy, the failure to cutomise an index to incorporate a UK equity home bias could create even greater controversy as some managers have found out[7].
Interestingly the proposed £5,000 UK ISA Allowance would make up 20% of a total £25,000 ISA contribution, so we remain comfortable with a 20% UK equity allocation within our multi-asset indices.
UK equities as a diversifier
Whilst US and World Equities have persistently outperformed the UK equity market, we think the UK equity market is looking interesting once again not just from a valuation perspective, and not necessarily from a returns perspective, but primarily as an equity portfolio diversifier owing to its decorrelation from the US.
The structure of the UK equity market (low valuation, value/yield bias, old-world defensive sectors such as energy, mining, healthcare) is so different to the structure of the US equity market (high valuation, growth bias, new-world technology sector concentration), that they complement each other rather well as a diversifier.
Recall 2022, the inflation shock from the Russia/Ukraine war and related sanctions meant that the UK equity market was up, when the US and hence world equities were down.
Similarly this year, the UK equity market has frequently moved inversely to the US and World equities.
Fig.3. US and World Equities move lock-step, UK equities do not
[see pdf version]
Whilst US and World equities move lock-step, the different return “pattern” for UK equities makes it an interesting diversifier from a portfolio construction perspective: The measure of “true diversification” is correlation.  By combining lower correlated assets, the risk of the whole can be less than the sum of parts.

 
Long-term and short-term correlations both matter
When building long-term strategic asset allocation models, asset allocators look at long-term risk, return and correlation structure (either forward-looking estimates or historical data) and refresh this every few years.
Using 10 year historic data as at end 2023, the US and UK correlation to world equities is 0.97 and 0.80 respectively.
However to understand current market conditions and how portfolios are actually behaving, it is also important to look at short-term correlations.  Using rolling 1 year correlation data, the US and UK correlation to world equities is 0.97 and 0.61 respectively.
Hence a portfolio built using long-run estimates will look very different to one built using short-run estimates.  This is why we believe in an adaptive approach to asset allocation that considers both long-run and short-run, risk and correlation structure.
Fig.4. Long-run and short-run correlations are similar for the US but different for the UK
[see pdf version]

The changing nature of UK equity correlation
As US equities make up a growing concentration of world equity indices, it is unsurprising that the short-run rolling 1 year correlation between US and World Equities remains consistently high (they move lock-step, as discussed above) and in line with its long-run figure.
By contrast, the short-run 1 year correlation of UK vs World Equities is not stable.  We can see two clear periods of material disconnect.  One following Brexit and the second following Covid and subsequent related inflation shock and the marked by divergence between tech-oriented US market and value-oriented UK market.
The chart below is why we are currently positive on the UK equity market.  Not just on valuation grounds, not just as a region- or sector-based diversifier, but as a genuinely less correlated market. Its lower correlation to World Equities, unlike the US, enables risk-based diversification within a portfolio’s equity allocation.
Fig.5. UK Equity has become less correlated with world equities increasing its diversifier status
[see pdf version]
For a defensive approach, think dividends
The UK equity market returns are underpinned by dividend generation.
Looking at the returns of the FTSE All-Share Index Total Returns (which includes reinvested dividends) and the FTSE All-Share Price Index (which assumes dividends are paid out and not reinvested), we can see that reinvested dividends represent 41.6% of cumulative total return of the UK equity market from 2008 to 2023 (see below).
This should prove even more defensive in challenging markets.

 
Fig.6. FTSE All Share: Total and Price Return and reinvested income contribution to returns
[see pdf version]
Summary
Whilst there have been significant recent outflows from UK equity funds, perhaps investors are missing one key consideration: that of decorrelation.
Having more than one global equity fund provides no diversification from a risk perspective.  They will likely move broadly in tandem, regardless of which active manager, and regardless as to whether its active or passively managed.
But pairing a global or US equity fund with a UK equity fund introduces true (risk-based) diversification within the equity portion of a portfolio because of the UK’s low correlation and very different and sometimes opposite return pattern.


[1] This is the current version of a long-standing index series currently called the MSCI PIMFA Private Investor Indices.  The original FTSE APCIMS Indices were renamed FTSE WMA Private Investor Indices in 1q14.  The WMA transferred its Private Investor Indices to MSCI from 1st March 2017, and they were renamed MSCI PIMFA Private Investor Indices on 1st June 2017, following the merger of the Wealth Management Association (WMA) and Association of Professional Financial Advisers (APFA).  We have combined the asset allocation history of the above indices to create a single time-series.

[2] The MSCI PIMA Private Investor Indices have an asset allocation determined by its index committee that aims to ensure that the asset allocation is reflective of its member firms.  The index committee includes representatives from Canaccord Genuity Wealth, Investec Wealth and Investments, Rathbones, JM Finn, Brooks MacDonald, Killik & Co, Close Brothers, Evelyn Partners, Quilter Cheviot and others.  For more information, see https://www.pimfa.co.uk/about-us/pimfa-groups/private-investor-indices-committee/

[3] See our July 2020 article https://www.elstonsolutions.co.uk/insights/home-equity-bias-is-irrational-and-has-been-penalised-uk-investors

[4] See our October 2021 article https://www.elstonsolutions.co.uk/insights/understanding-spiva

[5] See our December 2022 article https://www.elstonsolutions.co.uk/insights/are-active-managers-improving

[6] See https://www.elstonsolutions.co.uk/our-indices.html for more information

[7] https://www.peelhunt.com/news-insights/articles/selling-down-the-uk/

all eyes on the pivot

31/1/2024

 
Picture
Central Banks' policy rates are expected to pivot towards cuts in 2024 with a material impact on asset class perspectives.

Read More

Simple. Effective.  Equal-weight.

15/7/2022

 
Picture
[5 min read, open as pdf for full article]
  • A straightforward approach to reduce concentration risk
  • Reduces “the big get bigger” effect of cap-weighted “passive” indices
  • Scope for outperformance relative to traditional indices

Critics of tracker funds often flagged concentration risk or the “big get bigger” approach of passive investing as a structural flaw to index investing.  But concentration risk is a choice, not an obligation for the index investor.

​As would be expected, an equal weight approach has proved relatively more defensive in the down-market year-to-date.  The S&P500 Equal Weight index has returned -5.2% against the traditional S&P 500’s -9.3% YTD, in GBP terms.

For more on this topic, please see our CISI-endorsed CPD webinar:
The curious power of equal weight, with guest speaker Tim Edwards, Managing Director, Index Investment Strategy, S&P Dow Jones Indices

UK inflation and sterling pressure

18/5/2022

 
Picture
[5 min read, open as pdf]

  • UK inflation hits 40 year high
  • Bank of England has been behind the curve
  • Sterling under pressure – how to protect against inflation
 
Inflation hits 40 year high
UK inflation figures came out today with a print of +9.0%yy (April), from +7.0% (March) and slightly below +9.1%yy consensus estimate.
This is the highest level in 40 years, putting renewed focus on the “cost of living crisis”.  Rising energy and food costs are the primary drivers, linked to the sanctions regime and the Russia/Ukraine war.
The Bank of England has been “behind the curve” as regards to inflation risk.  A look at inflation guidance contained in recent Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) minutes shows.  Near-term inflation guidance has consistently under-estimated inflation since August 2021 – rising from “above 2%”, to 4%, 6%, 8%,, 9% and now 10%.
Read full article with charts

The rotation to Value has room to run

3/3/2022

 
Picture
[5 min read, open as pdf]

  • The late 2020 rotation to Value has been rewarded
  • Factor tilts align to economic cycle and inflation regime
  • Despite strong relative performance, Value-factor equities have room to run
 
The “great rotation” to Value began towards the end of 2020 as inflation fears came into focus.  It has been rewarded.

Since Dec 2020, the MSCI World Value factor has delivered +21.43% returns to 25th February 2022 compared to +7.70% return for Growth factor and +14.78% for the parent MSCI World index (a traditional market-cap based index), all in GBP terms.

If we look back further at relative performance since end 2007 to 25-Feb-22, we can see that Value’s underperformance relative to Growth is still material.

Over that period, Growth returned +369% (11.54%pa), compared to +179% (7.52%pa) for Value, and +268% (9.63%pa) for traditional market-cap based world equities, in GBP terms.
​
On this basis, the re-rating of Value, relative to Growth, has room to run in the face of a persistent inflationary regime.

Read full article with charts
Watch our CISI-accredited CPD on an Introduction to Factor Investing

UK value/income bias delivers performance in uncertain times

14/2/2022

 
Picture
 [3min read, open as pdf]
  • Value bias has made UK equities more attractive recently
  • Within UK equities, strategies with an income-bias has outperformed
  • “Smart-Beta” means a rules-based approach for constructing an index
 
Value/Income bias for inflation protection
In our 2022 outlook, we explained why inflation will remain hotter for longer and will settle above pre-pandemic levels.  Within equities, we outlined our rationale for being overweight Value-factor equities with an Income bias to shorten equity duration.  This built on our May 2021 view on UK equity income providing a helpful inflation hedge.

The rapidity and severity of market movements against the prospect of faster-than-expected inflation and greater-than-expected interest rate tightening have only served to reinforce these views, as reflected by performance.

Whereas world equities have struggled year to date, UK equities have been a relative bright spot.  Within UK equity index exposures, indices that focus on dividends (with an inherent value bias), over size (market cap) have delivered best results.
​
Our Smart-Beta UK Dividend Index [ticker ELSUKI Index] has delivered positive returns YTD ahead of more mainstream UK equity indices, driving the absolute and relative returns of the VT Munro Smart-Beta UK Fund, which is benchmarked to this index[1].

Read full article as pdf

[1] Note & Commercial Interest Disclosure: Elston Indices is the benchmark administrator for the Freedom Smart-Beta UK Dividend Index, to be renamed the Elston Smart-Beta UK Dividend Index with effect from 1st March 2022.  The VT Munro Smart-Beta UK Fund is benchmarked to this index.

Adapting portfolios for inflation

4/2/2022

 
Picture
[5 min read, open as pdf]

In our 2022 outlook, we explained why inflation will remain hotter for longer and will settle above pre-pandemic levels.  Advisers should consider how to adapt portfolios for inflation across each asset class – equities, bonds and alternatives.  Research demonstrates how different asset classes exhibit different degrees of inflation protection over different time-frames.  Equities therefore provide a long-term inflation hedge.
  • Short- to Medium-term:    rate-sensitive assets, commodities
  • Medium- to Long-term:     real estate, equities and inflation-linked
  • Long-term                             equities

In this article, we explore how to adapt portfolios for inflation within and across each asset class: Equities, Bonds and Alternatives.

For full article, read as pdf

equity income: value provides resilience

28/1/2022

 
Picture
[7 min read, open as open as pdf]
  • Equity Income total returns are underpinned by dividends
  • Equity income has a value-bias, which typically translates to outperformance in an inflationary regime
  • “Shorter-duration” equity income exposures make more sense with rising rates/ inflation

​Year to date performance
The dispersion between styles and segments within equities is pronounced in the UK.
Given recent market stress over the prospect of a rising interest rate environment, inflationary pressure, and geopolitical tensions, year-to-date performance underscores the relative resilience of equities with a Value/Income bias relative to other UK equity segments and world equities.
Year to date, world equities are down -5.93%, the FTSE All Share is flat at -0.55%.  UK Small Caps are down -8.49%, the FTSE 100 is +1.14% and UK Equity Income (Freedom Smart-Beta UK Dividend Index) is +3.97%.
This is because returns are underpinned by dividend income as well as exposure to energy and financials which benefit respectively from a high oil price/rising rate environment.

​Read in full as pdf

2022 outlook: key themes

11/1/2022

 
Picture

[3 min read,  open as pdf]
​
  • Adapting portfolios for inflation
  • Income generation in a negative real yield world
  • Positioning portfolios for climate transition
 
2021 in review
Our 2021 market roundup summarises another strong year for markets in almost all asset classes except for Bonds which remain under pressure as interest rates are expected to rise and inflation ticks up.
Listed private equity (shares in private equity managers) performed best at +43.08%yy in GBP terms.  US was the best performing region at +30.06%.
Real asset exposures, such as Water, Commodities and Timber continued to rally in face of rising inflation risk, returning +32.81%, +28.22% and +17.66% respectively.

2022 outlook
We are continuing in this “curiouser, through-the-looking glass” world.  Traditionally you bought bonds for income, and equity for risk.  Now it’s the other way round.
Only equities provide income yields that have the potential to keep ahead of inflation.  Bonds carry increasing risk of loss in real terms as inflation and interest rates rise.
Real yields, which are bond yields less the inflation rate, are negative making traditional Bonds which aren’t linked to inflation highly unattractive.  Bonds that are linked to inflation are highly sensitive to rising interest rates (called duration risk), so are not attractive either.
How to navigate markets in this context?
The big three themes for the year ahead are, in our view:
  1. Adapting portfolios for inflation
  2. Income generation in a negative real yield world
  3. Positioning portfolios for climate transition
We explore each in turn, as well as reviewing updated Capital Market Assumptions for expected returns from different asset classes.

See full report in pdf
Attend our 2022 Outlook webinar

Bracing for inflation: the opportunity in value

12/11/2021

 
Picture

  • Inflation: has ‘transitory’ taken on a whole new meaning?
  • Value investing in an inflationary environment
  • Capturing the opportunity

Inflation is proving more persistent than transitory.  In an inflationary environment, Value style investing has the potential for continued outperformance relative to other factors.  For UK fund investors, actively managed funds with a value-oriented philosophy, UK equity income funds with an inherent value bias and Value-factor index funds/ETFs offer ways of increasing allocation to Value within a portfolio.

Read the article (5 min read)
Watch the webinar

Value investing makes a come back

4/11/2021

 
Picture
  • The relationship between equity income, equity duration and value bias
  • Income focus, with inherent value bias, acts as potential inflation hedge
  • Negative real yields, and yield premium to gilts makes equity income investing attractive
 
The era of quantitative easing programmes have had a distorting effect on markets since the 2008 financial crisis has given value investors a torrid time in the past decade. The near-constant sugar-rush of liquidity has served to de-link valuations from underlying fundamentals prompting a huge bias towards growth. While pockets of investors have been braced for a long-expected correction that has never really materialised, the recent sharp increase in inflation may constitute an inflection point of sorts. In inflationary periods and when interest rates rise, the time horizon for future discounting shrinks, leaving equities exposed.
Income-yielding shares have an inherent value-bias, owing to the types of company that pay steady dependable dividend).  This provides a measure of inflation protection both in absolute terms and relative to nominal bonds.

Read the full article
Watch the webinar

The relationship between value & inflation

16/7/2021

 
Picture
[10 min read, open as pdf]

  • What underpins the Value/Inflation Relationship
  • Understanding the Value Cycle
  • Relative performance of Value in different inflationary regimes

equities with Value-bias and dividend growth provide inflation hedge

21/5/2021

 
Picture
[3 min read, open as pdf]

Inflation is on the rise: equities provide long-term inflation protection
Inflation risk means greater focus on intrinsic value such as dividends
UK equities with value and/or income bias are attractive

Inflation is on the rise, and whilst it’s broadly accepted that equities can provide a long-term inflation hedge, which kind of equities are best positioned to provide this. 
Since the financial crisis, Value investors have been jilted by a market love affair with Momentum.  The switch back to Value was already being called on purely a valuation basis since late 2019.  But the rekindling of inflation risk in the market is only making companies with a Value-bias and  a progressive quality income stream back in the spotlight.
What is quality income?
Quality means persistency, focusing on companies that regularly pay a stable or increasing dividend, whilst mitigating dividend concentration risk.

“One of the most persuasive tests of high quality is an uninterrupted record of dividend payments going back many years.”
Benjamin Graham
Indeed, research suggests that Dividends are a key anchor of Total Returns, although this differs from market to market.
Picture
Figure 1: Source: S&P Dow Jones Index Research August 2016
Figure 2: Source: JP Morgan, The Search for Income: A Global Dividend Strategy, 2012


How then to screen for companies that can deliver this type of strategy? Is it just about yield?  We don’t think so.

High yield is not high quality
Screening for high dividend yield alone can lead to “value-traps” that negatively impact performance.
The poor performance is because those high-yielding companies might be poor businesses with unstable dividends.

Market cap weight or Dividend contribution weight
Traditional equity indices are market-capitalisation weighted.  The resulting dividend income for an index is therefore a function of each company’s size.  An alternative approach is to weight the holding in each company by its contribution to overall dividends.  This way the index is focused on the biggest dividend payers, rather than the biggest companies by size.  This creates a direct bias towards Yield, and an indirect bias towards Value, from a factor-exposure perspective.

Forward- or backward-looking
Active equity income managers typically look at forward-looking dividend estimates.  Index-based “passive” equity income strategies often look at historic dividend yield for ranking purposes.  This is sub-optimal.  We believe that index strategies that focus on equity income should use forward-looking estimates, to systematically capture upswings in earnings and dividend estimates.
​
Equities as an inflation hedge
It’s broadly accepted that equities can provide a long-term inflation hedge.  But what kind of equities are likely to perform well in an inflationary regime?

We believe there are three characteristics:
  1. Real value: companies whose valuation is anchored by future dividend growth, as well as earnings growth
  2. Attractive valuations: companies on attractive earnings multiples relative to comparators, and relative to bonds (earning yield relative to bond yields)
  3. Rising return on capital: relative to their cost of capital
 
Why the Value focus in inflationary environment?
When the two major styles of investing are compared, i.e., growth and value investing, the latter style rejects the efficient market hypothesis and choses an equity with lower expectations, which is often undervalued and would profit quickly when the market adjusts itself.
During an inflationary environment, economic concepts direct that the ‘time value of money’ has a major role to play. Thus, an equity today, becomes of greater value, when compared to its worth tomorrow. Hence, value investing seems attractive in an inflationary world since the investors are less willing to pay up for future earnings and can regain their money sooner rather than later, when compared to growth investing. (Murphy, 2021)
With a global pandemic, many predicted deflation as a threat; however, with the counter-balancing forces, investors soon realized inflationary threat. (Baron, 2021). Rising inflation is good for value investing for a number of reasons. In general, equity markets are dynamic and display a stronger corelation to inflationary environment, this lays a very strong premise that higher inflation and stronger earnings are co-dependent. Financially speaking, Sectors such as energy, financial are major drivers of the major economic growth. A rise in these value stocks tends to pace up the overall economic growth, thus outperforming others. (Lebovitz,2021)
According to JP Morgan’s chief strategist, the change in investing style, this time around could be a more impactful due to several factors such as the failure of monetary and fiscal policies whilst recovering from a pandemic. (Ossinger, 2021)

Dividends, dividends, dividends: a tried and tested approach
The most fundamental explanation, by John Kingham, a value investor, states that a dividend discount model, attempts to find the true value of the stock, under any market circumstances and focuses on the dividend pay-out factors and the market expected returns. 
Historically, the companies with dividend have generated higher returns when compared to companies which either have no dividend or eliminated the dividend.  (Park and Chalupnik, 2021) This means that dividends hold value when it comes to the total return of the portfolio.
Moreover, with the market getting more and more inflationary, and equities getting exposed. Adding companies which can provide returns even in a low growth environment can create a sustainable portfolio.
Government bonds have not performed well with rising inflation (Baron,2021) High yielding corporate bonds offered better protection compared to government gilts since these inflations linked bonds add value in-line with RPI Inflation according to Barclays Equity Guilt Study and can protect investors from unexpected inflation, yet they are still not considered as a safe haven like government gilts. (Dillow,2021) Investment manager of Iboss Chris Rush recently told Portfolio Adviser that in order to reduce the inflationary shock the firm had already reduced its positions from treasures and gilts and incorporated strategic bonds They also plan on holding a short duration fixed income. (Cheek, 2021)
Although, it might have not been the fundamental goal, over the past several decades until 2017 dividends reported 42% of the S&P 500 Index’s total return. The global recession and now pandemic have created a lack of stability for the layer of support for future returns, however, analysts have assured there is room for recovery. (Markowicz, 2021)
 
Summary
Whether transitory or persistent, with inflation on the rise, there is a strong rationale for having an allocation to Value from a factor-exposure perspective.  Those value-type firms that generate and pay a progressive dividend policy provides a level of inflation protection both in absolute terms and relative to bonds that is more than welcome, and potentially essential.

Henry Cobbe & Aayushi Srivastava

Factor rotation ahead?

27/11/2020

 
Picture
[2 min read, open as pdf]

  • Momentum has been the best performing factor
  • Can factors get crowded, but can they be timed?
  • Will we see a persistent rotation to value?
 
A Factor-based approach to investing
Factor-based investing means choosing securities for an inclusion in an index based on what characteristics or factors drive their risk-return behaviour, rather than a particular geography or sector.
Just like food can be categorised simply by ingredients, it can also be analysed more scientifically by nutrients.  Factors are like the nutrients in an investment portfolio.
​
What are the main factors?
There is a realm of academic and empirical study behind the key investment factors, but they can be summarised as follows
The different factors can be summarised as follows:
  • Size: smaller capitalisation companies
  • Momentum: companies with upward price trend
  • Quality: companies with strong and stable earnings
  • Value: companies that are undervalued relative to their fundamentals
  • Min Volatility: companies with lower volatility performance characteristics
 
Which has been the strongest performing factor?
Momentum has been the best performing factor over the last 5 years.  Value has been the worst performing factor.
 
Fig.1. World equity factor performance
Picture
Source: Elston research, Bloomberg data

A crowded trade?
Data points to Momentum being a “crowded trade”, because of the number of people oerweighting stocks with momentum characteristics.  This level of crowdedness can be an indicator of potential drawdowns to come.
​
Fig.2. Momentum Factor is looking increasingly crowded
Picture
Source: MSCI Factor Crowding Model

The best time to buy into a Momentum strategy has been when it is uncrowded – like in 2001 and 2009, which is also true of markets more generally.  MSCI’s research suggests that with crowding scores greater than 1 were historically more likely to experience significant drawdowns in performance over subsequent months than factors with lower crowding scores.
​
Fig.3. Factors with higher crowding score can be an indicator of greater potential drawdowns, relative to less crowded factors
Picture
Source: MSCI Factor Crowding Model

Rotation to Value
The value-based approach to investing has delivered lack lustre performance in recent times, hence strategists’ calls that there may be a potential “rotation” into Value-oriented strategies in coming months as the post-COVID world normalises.  But can factors be timed?

Marketing timing, factor timing?
Market timing is notoriously difficult.  Factor timing is no different.  To get round this, a lot of fund providers have offered multi-factor strategies, which allocate to factors either statically or dynamically.  Whilst convenient as a catch-all solution, unless factor exposures are dynamically and actively managed, the exposure to all factors in aggregate will be similar to overall market exposure.  This has led to a loss of confidence and conviction in statically weighted multi-factor funds.

Summary
Factors help break down and isolate the core drivers of risk and return.
  • Factor investing looks at the “nutrients” of investment
  • Static “catch-all” approach to multi-factor investing has clear constraints, so a more dynamic approach makes sense
  • Factors can get crowded, but factor allocation is hard to time
 
For more on Factor investing, see
https://www.elstonsolutions.co.uk/insights/category/factor-investing  
​https://www.msci.com/factor-investing 

    ELSTON RESEARCH

    insights inform solutions

    Get our weekly newsletter

    Categories

    All
    All Weather Portfolio
    Alternative Assets
    Alternative Strategies
    Bonds
    Business Practice
    Capital Market Assumptions
    CPD
    Direct Gilts
    Equities
    Equity Income
    Equity Sectors
    ESG
    ETFs
    Evidence Based Investing
    Factor Investing
    Geopolitics
    Gold & Precious Metals
    Guide To Investing
    Index Investing
    Inflation
    Investment Trusts
    Macro
    MULTI ASSET
    Multi Asset Income
    Net Zero
    Outlook
    Permanent Portfolio
    Podcast
    Portfolio Construction
    Private Markets
    Real Assets
    Retirement Investing
    Risk Parity
    Thematic Investing
    Value Factor
    Video

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    June 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    August 2015
    June 2015
    January 2014
    June 2012

    RSS Feed

Company
Home
About
​Our Journey
​​​Contact
Terms of Use
​Our Solutions
​​Insights
​Our Portfolios
Custom Portfolios
​Retirement Portfolios
Our CGT Solutions
Our Funds
Custom Funds
Our Indices
Custom Indices
​Adviser Support
CIRP
Investment Committee Support
Regulatory Support
Analytics, Factsheets & Reporting
CPD


By client type:
For Advisers
For Discretionary Managers


© COPYRIGHT 2012-25. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
 Elston Consulting Limited (Company Registration Number 07125478) is registered in
England & Wales, Registered address:  1 King William Street, London EC4N 7AF
  • WHO WE ARE
    • About
    • Our Journey
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Elston MPS >
      • Our Portfolios
      • Adaptive Portfolios
      • Retirement Portfolios
      • Multi-Asset Income
      • Money Market Portfolio
    • Custom MPS >
      • Custom Portfolios
    • CGT Solutions >
      • Our CGT Solutions
      • GIA Portfolios
      • Onshore Bonds
      • Direct Gilts
    • Adviser Support >
      • Our Adviser Support
      • CIRP
      • Investment Committee Support
      • Regulatory Support
      • Analytics, Factsheets & Reporting
      • CPD
    • Fund Solutions >
      • Our Funds
      • Custom Funds
    • Index Solutions >
      • Our Indices
      • Elston Multi-Asset Indices
      • Sector Equal Weight
      • UK Equity Income
      • Liquid Real Assets
      • Gold and Precious Metals
      • Custom Indices
  • WHO WE HELP
    • Financial Advisers
    • Discretionary Managers
  • Insights
  • Contact